Carnahan Jewelers

Name: Carnahan Jewelers
Address: 126 E Main St, Eaton, OH, 45320
Telephone: +1 937-456-4664
Rating: 4.67

4.67 • Excellent ReputationBased on 3 reviews

Visit website

Own this business? Click here to claim it.

Carnahan Jewelers is a jeweler in Eaton, Ohio, rated 4.67 out of 5 from 3 customer reviews published on Goldiew.

Call Directions

FREE TOOLSelling gold jewelry?Get a live-price estimate of the metal value first, and see what four buyer types typically pay.Check gold value →FREE SERVICEGet competing offers for your jewelryDescribe your items once and rated buyers quote their best price. Free, private, and your contact stays hidden until you accept an offer.Get my offers →

★ 4.67

All reviews

Average rating based on 3 reviews

6 months ago

A decent jewelry store with friendly staff and fair prices

Visited this jewelry store without a clear idea of what I wanted and ended up browsing for quite a while. The staff was friendly but not overly eager to push suggestions, which felt refreshing. They showed me several pieces that caught my eye, though nothing really stood out as perfect. Prices were reasonable and the selection decent enough if you're just casually looking around. My overall visit was fine, no strong impressions either way other than it’s okay worth checking out if you happen to be in town or passing by with some free time on your hands. Not memorable enough for frequent visits but service was adequate when needed.

Date: April 10, 2026 · Ref. ID: #41806

6 months ago

a calming shop with lovely jewelry and interesting finds

There was a quiet calm about the place that immediately put me at ease. The selection of jewelry was lovely, and I appreciated how attentive the staff seemed without being overbearing. At first, I thought it might be too traditional for my taste but then noticed some unique pieces tucked away in corners which changed my view slightly, I wouldn’t say completely sold yet but definitely intrigued enough to keep browsing. Prices were reasonable considering craftsmanship quality, making it easy to imagine something special without feeling pressured. It’s one of those spots where you leave with a good impression even if you’re not sure exactly what you're looking for beforehand, peacefully impressed overall.

Date: April 7, 2026 · Ref. ID: #41637

9 months ago

Turns out this place is better than I thought

Honestly, I didn't have high expectations going in. Sometimes with jewelers you just expect the usual service and nothing more. But this place surprised me a bit. The selection was decent, and they were patient when helping me choose something special for my partner. It’s not exactly over-the-top or fancy but it gets the job done well enough. Imagine if… Well, maybe that’s what kept things simple but effective at least for now. Overall, no real complaints, they did everything as promised and then some without making big promises either because honestly I wasn’t expecting much beyond basic quality here anyway so I guess it worked out fine altogether.

Date: December 27, 2025 · Ref. ID: #36164

Looking for similar businesses near Carnahan Jewelers?
Click to explore related listings.

Before you sell

Business details

Carnahan Jewelers is a Jeweler located at 126 E Main St, Eaton, OH 45320. Here is a list of all the activities that Carnahan Jewelers specializes in: Jeweler.

Contact info

http://carnahan-jewelers.keeq.io/
+1 937-456-4664
126 E Main St, Eaton, OH 45320
45320

Open Hours

Closed · Opens in 4h 2m

Monday: 10 AM-5 PM
Tuesday: 10 AM-5 PM
Wednesday: 10 AM-5 PM
Thursday: Closed
Friday: 10 AM-5 PM
Saturday: 10 AM-5 PM
Sunday: Closed

Opening hours and open/closed status for Carnahan Jewelers are shown based on their local time zone.

Time Zone

America/New_York

Services offered by Carnahan Jewelers

Discover the services provided by Carnahan Jewelers, grouped by category to help you understand what they specialize in.

Carnahan Jewelers has not claimed this page yet. Services listed have not been verified directly by the business.

Buying services

Buy scrap jewelry

Jewelry services

New fine jewelry sales

Custom jewelry design

Bridal / engagement rings

Estate‑jewelry resale

Loose gemstones for sale

Repairs & appraisals

Jewelry repair & resizing

Watch repair / batteries

Stone setting

Professional cleaning

Insurance jewelry appraisal

Estate appraisal

Pawn & financing services

Pawn loans on jewelry

Business categories & location

See what type of business Carnahan Jewelers is and where they operate. Click any state or city to explore more businesses of the same type in that location.

Jeweler

Jewelry store

About Carnahan Jewelers

Carnahan Jewelers is a jeweler located in Eaton, Ohio. The business offers various types of jewelry, including rings, necklaces, earrings, bracelets, and watches. In addition to selling jewelry, Carnahan Jewelers also offers repair services, such as ring resizing, prong replacement, and stone replacement. The shop is open for business during regular business hours, and customers can visit the store in person or place orders online. This description is based solely on factual data and aims to provide an unbiased overview of the business, without any reference to the reliability, quality, or other factors related to the business.

Verified social profiles

This business has not added any verified social profiles yet.

How Carnahan Jewelers Measures Up on Our Safety Index
Rating & Label	Meaning
5.00 - 4.50 ✅ Excellent Reputation	Consistently rated highly by users. Strong trustworthiness.
4.49 - 3.80 🟢 Good Standing	Generally well-reviewed with some concerns.
3.79 - 2.80 ⚠️ Mixed Feedback	Reviews vary; some report good experiences, others have concerns.
2.79 - 1.80 🟠 Needs Improvement	Multiple negative reviews highlight recurring issues.
1.79 - 1.00 🔴 Poor Reputation	Generally low-rated with significant concerns.
⏳ Awaiting Reviews	This company has not been reviewed yet.

Note: The Safety Index for Carnahan Jewelers is based on an average user rating of 4.67 from 3 user reviews. This rating determines the company’s reputation level: Excellent Reputation.

Carnahan Jewelers

All reviews

A decent jewelry store with friendly staff and fair prices

a calming shop with lovely jewelry and interesting finds

Turns out this place is better than I thought

Before you sell

Business details

Contact info

Open Hours

Time Zone

Services offered by Carnahan Jewelers

Buying services

Jewelry services

Repairs & appraisals

Pawn & financing services

Business categories & location

Jeweler

Jewelry store

About Carnahan Jewelers

Verified social profiles

More businesses like Carnahan Jewelers

Heins Jewelers

Dixon Jewelers Inc

Cleveland Jewelry Exchange

Michael's Jewelry Center Inc

Gold & Diamonds Inc.

Dewitt Diamond & Gold Exchange

House Of Stones

Great American Jewelry - Washington Court House

Not finding what you're looking for?

Register to Claim This Business

Login