D'angelos Pawners & Jewelers
· Opens tomorrow 9:30 AM
6920 S Stony Is Ave, Chicago, IL 60649
41 coin dealers found in Chicago, IL
41 coin dealer match your search criteria
Show legend
Unrated business
Rated business (average user rating shown)
Cluster of businesses
Unrated businessRated business (average user rating shown)Cluster of businessesTap or click on a marker to view company details.
Tap outside this box to close it.
Show on map
Show legendUnrated businessRated business (average user rating shown)Cluster of businesses
Unrated businessRated business (average user rating shown)Cluster of businessesTap or click on a marker to view company details.
Tap outside this box to close it.
Show on map
More options in Chicago, Illinois
41 coin dealer match your search criteria
Visiting a coin shop in Chicago: what to know first
Chicago concentrates a large share of the Midwest coin trade, from downtown storefronts to suburban shops, and the search queries we see confirm it: coin buyers in Chicago are among the most looked-for in the country. Use that density: with this many rated shops within reach, there is no reason to accept a first quote on a collection. Know your melt value, flag anything that might be collectible, and bring ID, since Illinois law requires dealers to record purchases. The rankings above come from verified customer reviews, each checked by a human before it counts.
41 listed businesses · 73 verified customer reviews · top rating 5/5 (live figures from this directory)
Illinois exempts investment bullion and qualifying coins from sales tax, then taxes your gains at a flat 4.95%
Under 35 ILCS 120/2-5, Illinois exempts legal tender, currency, medallions, and gold or silver coinage from qualifying governments, plus bullion, from state sales tax. When you sell at a profit, Illinois taxes that gain at its flat 4.95% individual income tax rate. Dealers who buy from the public must comply with the Illinois Precious Metal Purchasing Act, which sets record-keeping and holding requirements.
Selling or buying coins locally: common questions
How do I know if my coins are worth more than their metal value?
Three things put a coin above melt: a scarce date, a scarce mint mark, and condition. Start with our free guide on collectible value versus melt, then get an in-person opinion from a shop listed on this page before selling anything old for scrap. The metal price sets your floor, never your ceiling.
What should I bring when selling coins in Illinois?
A government-issued photo ID (dealers who buy from the public record seller identity in most states), the coins in whatever holders they are already in (do not clean them), and your own melt-value estimate from a free calculator so you can judge offers on the spot.
Should I accept the first offer a coin dealer makes?
Compare at least two offers on anything above a few hundred dollars. Offers vary legitimately between shops depending on their inventory and clientele. You can also post one free request on our marketplace and let rated buyers quote their best price before you visit anyone.
Is it safe to mail coins to a distant buyer instead?
Reputable mail-in buyers use insured, tracked shipping and quote after receipt. It widens your options beyond local shops, at the cost of a few days. For rare coins, an in-person appraisal first is usually worth it. Our selling guides explain both routes step by step.