Costello’s Rare Coins is a coin dealer in Halesite, New York, rated 4.25 out of 5 from 4 customer reviews published on Goldiew.
Average rating based on 4 reviews
Really liked checking out the coins here, they are very knowledgeable. Just a tiny rim ding on one coin but overall it was an enjoyable visit and I will come back again.
Visiting the shop felt like stepping into a treasure trove of history. The staff was knowledgeable and patient, answering all my questions about inherited coins that came from family archives. Others before me had left with newfound confidence in their collections thanks to clear explanations and honest guidance. I appreciated how they took the time to handle my pieces carefully and offered valuable insights without rushing through it All in all it was a solid experience that reassured me I was making informed decisions on what has been passed down for generations
THIS PLACE REALLY IMPRESSED ME. THE SELECTION OF RARE COINS IS PRETTY OUTSTANDING AND PRICES ARE FAIR, WHICH MAKES IT EASY TO TRUST YOUR NEXT PURCHASE WILL BE WORTHWHILE. STAFF WAS FRIENDLY AND KNOWLEDGEABLE WITHOUT OVERWHELMING YOU WITH TOO MUCH INFO AT ONCE. I APPRECIATED THAT THEY GAVE GOOD ADVICE BUT ALSO ALLOWED ME TO MAKE MY OWN DECISION WITHOUT PRESSURE. EVERYTHING FELT SO ORGANIZED AND PROFESSIONAL FROM START TO FINISH. IF YOU’RE LOOKING FOR QUALITY COINS WITH GREAT SERVICE, THIS SPOT DEFINITELY DELIVERS!
Finding honest appraisals here is hit or miss; sometimes I leave with what I need, other times it feels like they’re not really interested. Not sure if I'll go back again.
Looking for similar businesses near Costello's Rare Coins?
Click to explore related listings.
Costello's Rare Coins is a Coin dealer located at 187 Park Ave, Halesite, NY 11743. Here is a list of all the activities that Costello's Rare Coins specializes in: Coin dealer.
· Opens tomorrow 11:00 AM
Monday: 11 AM-6 PM
Tuesday: 11 AM-6 PM
Wednesday: 11 AM-6 PM
Thursday: 11 AM-6 PM
Friday: 11 AM-6 PM
Saturday: 11 AM-6 PM
Sunday: 11 AM-6 PM
Opening hours and open/closed status for Costello's Rare Coins are shown based on their local time zone.
Discover the services provided by Costello's Rare Coins, grouped by category to help you understand what they specialize in.
Costello's Rare Coins has not claimed this page yet. Services listed have not been verified directly by the business.
See what type of business Costello's Rare Coins is and where they operate. Click any state or city to explore more businesses of the same type in that location.
Costello's Rare Coins is located in Halesite, New York and offers a wide range of collectible coins and banknotes, both ancient and modern. Their inventory includes U.S. coins, foreign coins, ancient coins, gold and silver coins, and bullion. They are also known for their expertise in appraising precious metals and rare coins. This description is solely based on factual data and aims to provide an unbiased and objective overview of Costello's Rare Coins as a coin dealer in Halesite, New York. It does not indicate any information regarding the reliability, trustworthiness, or any other factor related to the business.
This business has not added any verified social profiles yet.
| Rating & Label | Meaning |
|---|---|
| 5.00 - 4.50 ✅ Excellent Reputation | Consistently rated highly by users. Strong trustworthiness. |
| 4.49 - 3.80 🟢 Good Standing | Generally well-reviewed with some concerns. |
| 3.79 - 2.80 ⚠️ Mixed Feedback | Reviews vary; some report good experiences, others have concerns. |
| 2.79 - 1.80 🟠 Needs Improvement | Multiple negative reviews highlight recurring issues. |
| 1.79 - 1.00 🔴 Poor Reputation | Generally low-rated with significant concerns. |
| ⏳ Awaiting Reviews | This company has not been reviewed yet. |
Note: The Safety Index for Costello's Rare Coins is based on an average user rating of 4.25 from 4 user reviews. This rating determines the company’s reputation level: Good Standing.
· Opens tomorrow 10:00 AM
670 Old Willets Path, Hauppauge, NY 11788
· Opens tomorrow 10:00 AM
251-26 Northern Blvd, Queens, NY 11362
· Opens tomorrow 9:00 AM
40 Broadway, Hawthorne, NY 10532
· Opens tomorrow 10:00 AM
629 Sunrise Hwy, Lynbrook, NY 11563
We don't know the opening hours for this company
3 Computer Dr W Ste 122, Albany, NY 12205
We don't know the opening hours for this company
58 Old Quogue Rd, Riverhead, NY 11901
48 W 48th St STE 1201, New York, NY 10036
We don't know the opening hours for this company
Discover more businesses with our national business finder:
Visit our National Coin Dealer FinderOnce you’re on the page:
Results from nearby cities will appear instantly.
