Could be better with more guidance
Decent selection but the staff was somewhat unengaged, making it hard to get helpful advice. Prices seemed alright but overall a little underwhelming.
Date: June 30, 2026 · Ref. ID: #46119
Colony Coin Co is a coin dealer in Newtonville, Massachusetts, rated 3.83 out of 5 from 6 customer reviews published on Goldiew.
COIN COLLECTORSSelling collectible coins?Key dates and rarities are worth more than melt value. Learn what to check before you sell.Check collectible value →FREE SERVICEGet competing offers for your coinsDescribe your items once and rated buyers quote their best price. Free, private, and your contact stays hidden until you accept an offer.Get my offers →
★ 3.83
All reviews
Average rating based on 6 reviews
Good for a quick visit but not much to write home about
WANTED to test the waters with this coin dealer. They were pretty friendly and straightforward, but nothing really blew me away. GOOD for a quick visit, though perhaps I’ll explore more options next time.
Date: April 16, 2026 · Ref. ID: #42099
Handled my coins with care, made me feel at home
I was a bit worried about the patchy strike, but they handled my coins with care and made me feel like family. Definitely worth trusting for any coin needs!
Date: March 26, 2026 · Ref. ID: #40962
Nice spot to browse coins and find goodies
Great place to browse a variety of coins; the staff was friendly and helpful. Minor stain on one item but overall very satisfied with my purchase.
Date: November 16, 2025 · Ref. ID: #33963
Good spot for coins and fair prices
The coin selection is solid and easy to browse, with fair pricing. The staff member who helped me was dressed casually in a hoodie and jeans, which was unexpected but friendly. Overall, the visit met my expectations without exceeding them. A reliable spot for coins nearby.
Date: September 14, 2025 · Ref. ID: #30539
Coin finds and good vibes again
i found some coins just lying loose with others and it was pretty cool. the place had a chill vibe and I got what i was looking for without any fuss, will go back again!
Date: August 5, 2025 · Ref. ID: #28421
Looking for similar businesses near Colony Coin Co?
Click to explore related listings.
Before you sell your coins
COIN COLLECTORSSelling collectible coins?Key dates and rarities are worth more than melt value. Learn what to check before you sell.Check collectible value →FREE SERVICEGet competing offers for your coinsDescribe your items once and rated buyers quote their best price. Free, private, and your contact stays hidden until you accept an offer.Get my offers →
Business details
Colony Coin Co is a Coin dealer located at 78 Bowers St, Newtonville, MA 02460. Here is a list of all the activities that Colony Coin Co specializes in: Coin dealer.
Contact info
- +1 617-244-1972
- 78 Bowers St, Newtonville, MA 02460
- 02460
- Newtonville
Open Hours
· Opens Thursday 10:30 AM
Monday: 1-5:30 PM
Tuesday: Closed
Wednesday: Closed
Thursday: 10:30 AM-5:30 PM
Friday: Closed
Saturday: 9:30 AM-5:30 PM
Sunday: Closed
Opening hours and open/closed status for Colony Coin Co are shown based on their local time zone.
Time Zone
America/New_York
Services offered by Colony Coin Co
Discover the services provided by Colony Coin Co, grouped by category to help you understand what they specialize in.
Colony Coin Co has not claimed this page yet. Services listed have not been verified directly by the business.
Bullion products
Gold bullion rounds
Silver bullion bars / rounds
Certified rare coins
Raw collectible coins
Junk‑silver bags
Coin accessories
Buying services
Buy gold bullion
Buy rare coins
Price‑match guarantee
Repairs & appraisals
Professional cleaning
Coin grading submission
Estate appraisal
Pawn & financing services
Pawn loans on bullion/coins
Business categories & location
See what type of business Colony Coin Co is and where they operate. Click any state or city to explore more businesses of the same type in that location.
Gold dealer
Coin dealer
Jewelry buyer
About Colony Coin Co
Colony Coin Co is a coin dealer located in Newtonville, Massachusetts. They specialize in buying and selling coins of various types. Their services include appraisals, grading, and authentication of coins. Colony Coin Co has a wide selection of rare coins to choose from, and their staff is knowledgeable and professional. Their location is easily accessible and convenient for customers. This description is based on factual data only and aims to be unbiased. It does not indicate the reliability or any other factors related to the business.
Verified social profiles
This business has not added any verified social profiles yet.
| Rating & Label | Meaning |
|---|---|
| 5.00 - 4.50 ✅ Excellent Reputation | Consistently rated highly by users. Strong trustworthiness. |
| 4.49 - 3.80 🟢 Good Standing | Generally well-reviewed with some concerns. |
| 3.79 - 2.80 ⚠️ Mixed Feedback | Reviews vary; some report good experiences, others have concerns. |
| 2.79 - 1.80 🟠 Needs Improvement | Multiple negative reviews highlight recurring issues. |
| 1.79 - 1.00 🔴 Poor Reputation | Generally low-rated with significant concerns. |
| ⏳ Awaiting Reviews | This company has not been reviewed yet. |
Note: The Safety Index for Colony Coin Co is based on an average user rating of 3.83 from 6 user reviews. This rating determines the company’s reputation level: Good Standing.
More businesses like Colony Coin Co
Cape Cod Gold & Silver Coin
· Opens tomorrow 10:00 AM
424 Main St #3156, Falmouth, MA 02540
The Robyn's Nest
C & J Coins & Jewelry
· Opens tomorrow 10:00 AM
166 Main St, Woburn, MA 01801
New England Coins And Collectibles
· Opens tomorrow 8:30 AM
7 Day Ave, Westfield, MA 01085
Northeast Numismatics
· Opens tomorrow 10:00 AM
100 Main St #330, Concord, MA 01742
Whaling City Collectibles
· Opens tomorrow 9:30 AM
33 Center St, Fairhaven, MA 02719
Coin Replicas Corp.
· Opens tomorrow 10:00 AM
11 Chestnut St, Amesbury, MA 01913
West Bridgewater Coin And Jewelry Buyers Llc
· Opens tomorrow 10:00 AM
455 W Center St, West Bridgewater, MA 02379
Not finding what you're looking for?
Discover more businesses with our national business finder:
Visit our National Coin Dealer FinderOnce you’re on the page:
- Click the “Filters” button to open the search panel.
- Enter a city, postal code, or full address in the location field.
- Select your desired search radius (e.g. 20 miles).
- Optionally refine results by ratings, services, or business name.
Results from nearby cities will appear instantly.