Quick answer
The exemption lives in New York Tax Law section 1115(a)(27) and is administered under Technical Services Bulletin TSB-M-89(20)S, which translates the statute into concrete markup ratios: bullion bars and ingots at 115 percent of metal value or less, large gold coins at 115 percent, small gold coins (one-quarter ounce or less) at 120 percent, silver coins at 140 percent. Jewelry, numismatic premium pieces, platinum coins outside the ratio bands, and any qualifying order of $1,000 or less are all taxed. In New York City the combined rate is 8.875 percent.
Why New York taxes bullion at all
New York imposes sales tax on tangible personal property as its baseline rule and then carves out specific exemptions by statute. Precious metal bullion sits in that second bucket. The state treats a large investment-scale bullion purchase as an investment instrument and exempts it, while a smaller retail-size purchase is treated as tangible personal property and taxed in full.
The rule you actually pay is set by two documents. The statute is New York Tax Law section 1115(a)(27), which exempts “precious metal bullion sold for investment.” The administrative guidance that every dealer uses to apply the statute at the register is TSB-M-89(20)S. The statute sets the threshold and the general principle. The TSB-M sets the exact markup ratios that tell a dealer whether a given coin or bar is “sold for investment” or whether its premium is high enough that the transaction looks numismatic and becomes taxable.
Point of delivery drives the applicable rate. New York sales tax applies to retail sales delivered inside New York, which includes online orders shipped to a New York address by an out-of-state dealer that has nexus with the state. If the dealer does not collect, the buyer owes New York compensating use tax at the same combined rate for the delivery address, reported on the state income tax return or on a separate use tax return.
The $1,000 single-transaction threshold
Section 1115(a)(27) exempts bullion “sold for investment,” and the statute defines that phrase by reference to the price of the sale. Bullion is deemed sold for investment when the single transaction is for more than one thousand dollars. The threshold is strict: a $1,001 qualifying order can be exempt, while a $1,000 order is fully taxable. The dollar line is drawn at the invoice total of qualifying items, not at a per-item price.
Unlike California, which rounds the inflation-adjusted threshold upward every few years, New York has kept the $1,000 figure in statute since the exemption was enacted. The number has not moved. Dealers apply it exactly as written.
| Transaction size | Qualifying items | New York sales tax treatment |
|---|---|---|
| $1,000 or less | Any combination of bars, ingots, or coins of gold, silver, platinum, palladium, rhodium, ruthenium, or iridium | Fully taxed at combined state and local rate for the delivery address |
| More than $1,000 | Same qualifying items, provided each item’s price falls within the TSB-M markup ratio | Fully exempt on each qualifying line item |
| Any amount | Jewelry, numismatic coins priced above the ratio band, art bars sold well above spot | Fully taxed regardless of order size |
Two customers walking out of the same Manhattan coin shop can pay very different tax bills on nearly identical orders. A $990 order of silver eagles is fully taxed at the New York City combined rate of 8.875 percent. The same order at $1,010 is exempt in full on the qualifying lines. The dealer looks at the invoice, confirms the markup is inside the TSB-M band, and marks the ticket exempt or taxable accordingly.
The TSB-M-89(20)S markup ratios
Section 1115(a)(27) requires that the sale price depend only on the metal content for the exemption to apply. TSB-M-89(20)S translates that requirement into four numeric safe harbors. If the retail price falls at or below the applicable ratio of the daily metal value (or face value for coins, whichever is greater), the item is treated as bullion sold for investment and qualifies for the exemption. Above the ratio, the item is treated as numismatic or collectible and taxed.
| Product category | Maximum markup over metal value | Example products |
|---|---|---|
| Bars and ingots (any eligible metal) | 115 percent | LBMA-listed gold bars, silver bars, PAMP Suisse, Valcambi, Perth Mint bars |
| Gold coins larger than one-quarter ounce | 115 percent | 1 oz American gold eagle, 1 oz Canadian maple leaf, 1 oz krugerrand |
| Gold coins one-quarter ounce or less | 120 percent | 1/10 oz and 1/4 oz American gold eagles, fractional maple leafs |
| Silver coins | 140 percent | American silver eagle, Canadian silver maple leaf, Austrian philharmonic silver |
The ratio compares the retail price to the greater of the daily closing cash price of the metal or the coin’s face value at prevailing exchange rates. For silver coins the 140 percent band is wide because silver eagles historically carry a premium of 20 to 40 percent over spot, so the band preserves the exemption on normal retail transactions. For gold coins, the band is tighter because gold bullion coins typically trade close to spot. Fractional gold gets a slightly wider 120 percent band because the smaller the coin, the higher the per-ounce fabrication premium.
Platinum, palladium, rhodium, ruthenium, and iridium are included in the statute as eligible metals for bars and ingots. For coins, the ratio bands as written in the TSB-M cover gold and silver explicitly. Platinum coins such as the American platinum eagle are typically evaluated against the bars and ingots rule or against dealer-standard practice at the register. Confirm the dealer’s treatment on any platinum or palladium coin purchase before the sale.
What qualifies as exempt bullion
Section 1115(a)(27) covers “bars, ingots or coins” of the seven listed metals (gold, silver, platinum, palladium, rhodium, ruthenium, iridium) purchased for investment purposes and held in their original form without further manufacturing. The emphasis on “original form” is the dividing line between bullion and jewelry. A one-ounce gold round is bullion. A one-ounce gold pendant stamped with the same purity is jewelry.
Bars and ingots
Rectangular or square cast or minted bars from recognized refiners. Products from LBMA Good Delivery refiners such as PAMP Suisse, Valcambi, Argor-Heraeus, Perth Mint, and Royal Canadian Mint bars all fit the category. Generic silver bars from recognized domestic mints qualify at the 115 percent ratio. A 1 kilo silver bar priced at or below 115 percent of 32.15 ounces of spot silver is exempt on a sale over $1,000.
Bullion coins
Government-issued coins whose price tracks their metal content within the TSB-M bands. American gold and silver eagles, Canadian maple leafs, Austrian philharmonics, South African krugerrands, Australian kangaroos, and British sovereigns all qualify when the retail price falls inside the applicable ratio. The fact that a coin is legal tender does not alone make it exempt in New York; the price has to be inside the band.
What investment coins do not include
Numismatic coins sold at a premium above the ratio band are treated as collectibles rather than bullion. A graded MS-65 Saint-Gaudens double eagle priced at $4,000 against a melt value of roughly $2,500 sits above the 115 percent gold-coin band and is fully taxable even though the underlying metal is the same gold the exemption was designed to cover. The TSB-M draws the line at the markup, not at the coin’s rarity in the abstract.
What does not qualify (fully taxable in New York)
Several categories that buyers often expect to be covered by a precious metals exemption are in fact fully taxable in New York, regardless of transaction size.
- Jewelry. Rings, chains, necklaces, bracelets, watches, and any item of fabricated adornment are taxable. A $10,000 gold chain does not become exempt because it crosses the $1,000 threshold. The statute requires the metal be in “original form” as bars, ingots, or coins.
- Numismatic coins priced above the TSB-M band. Graded rarities, key dates, and proof issues priced at a numismatic premium above the applicable ratio are taxable at the full combined rate.
- Any qualifying order of $1,000 or less. A $1,000 order of American silver eagles is taxable in full. One more coin that pushes the invoice to $1,010 flips the whole transaction to exempt on the qualifying lines.
- Fabricated art bars sold well above spot. Silver bars stamped as collectibles or art pieces and priced substantially above metal value may be coded taxable even on a large order. Ask before purchase.
- Accessories and storage. Coin tubes, capsules, flips, slabs, safes, display cases, and shipping insurance are separate taxable items on the invoice. They do not count toward the $1,000 threshold and remain taxable even when the bullion portion of the order is exempt.
The combined tax rate: state base plus local additions
New York levies a 4 percent statewide sales and use tax, and every county plus New York City layers additional local sales tax on top. The combined rate paid at the register depends on the delivery address.
| Rate component | Amount | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Statewide base rate | 4.00% | New York Department of Taxation and Finance (fixed statewide) |
| New York City local sales tax | 4.50% | City of New York Department of Finance |
| Metropolitan Commuter Transportation District surcharge | 0.375% | Applies in the MCTD region (NYC, Nassau, Suffolk, Westchester, Rockland, Orange, Putnam, Dutchess) |
| Combined rate in New York City | 8.875% | City of New York Department of Finance |
| Combined rate range statewide | 7.00% to 8.875% | Varies by county; use the state rate lookup for an exact address |
The rate that applies to a taxable bullion purchase is the combined rate at the delivery address, not the buyer’s home address. A Buffalo resident who buys from a Manhattan coin shop and ships to the Buffalo home pays the Erie County combined rate. The same buyer picking up in Manhattan pays 8.875 percent New York City.
Combined rates can change when counties revise their local sales tax rates by resolution. Confirm the applicable rate for the delivery address on the New York State sales tax rates bulletin or the state rate lookup before any invoice large enough to matter.
Three worked scenarios around the $1,000 line
Three New York buyers help show how the threshold and markup bands interact in practice. Each scenario assumes delivery inside New York City at the 8.875 percent combined rate; adjust the rate for a different delivery address.
| Scenario | Order detail | Tax outcome |
|---|---|---|
| Scenario A: Below the line | $990 of American silver eagles, priced inside the 140 percent silver-coin band, shipped to a Brooklyn address | Fully taxable at 8.875 percent. Tax due is roughly $87.86. Order total is roughly $1,077.86. |
| Scenario B: Just above the line | $1,050 of 1-ounce American gold eagles, priced inside the 115 percent large-gold band, shipped to a Manhattan address | Fully exempt on the gold lines. No sales tax. Buyer saves roughly $93.19 versus the same order structured one coin smaller. |
| Scenario C: Mixed basket | $1,500 invoice: $1,200 of generic 1 oz gold bars at 112 percent markup, plus $300 of graded Morgan silver dollars sold at 180 percent of melt | Gold bars exempt (inside 115 percent band and total order over $1,000). Morgan dollars taxable (above the 140 percent silver-coin band because the price depends on numismatic premium, not metal content). Tax due is roughly $26.63 on the Morgan dollars only. |
Scenario C is the one dealers see most often. Mixed invoices with a bullion portion and a numismatic portion are coded line by line, not in a single all-or-nothing exemption. The buyer pays tax on the numismatic lines and no tax on the bullion lines, as long as the overall transaction is over $1,000 and each exempt line’s markup falls inside the TSB-M band. For a quick independent sanity check on the melt value of coins or bars you are considering, see the Goldiew gold value calculator.
Online orders and New York use tax
Most major online precious metals dealers now collect New York sales tax at checkout on orders that fall below the exemption threshold or outside the markup bands. This follows the economic nexus rules that New York adopted after the Supreme Court’s decision in South Dakota v. Wayfair in 2018. Dealers with gross sales of $500,000 and 100 transactions into New York in a four-quarter window are required to register and collect.
The practical result for a New York buyer: on a qualifying bullion order over $1,000 shipped to a New York address, the invoice should show no sales tax. On a bullion order of $1,000 or less, or on any numismatic or jewelry line, the invoice should show tax at the combined rate for the ship-to address. Cross-check the invoice. Dealers occasionally misclassify borderline items, and the buyer owes any missed use tax.
If you buy from a smaller out-of-state dealer that does not collect New York tax and your order is $1,000 or less, you technically owe New York compensating use tax at the combined rate for your delivery address. Report use tax on the New York personal income tax return (form IT-201 or IT-203) or directly to the Department of Taxation and Finance. Enforcement against individuals on personal bullion purchases is limited but the legal duty exists.
How New York dealers apply the exemption at checkout
Every New York dealer has to make the tax decision on every invoice. The workflow is straightforward and there are several points where a customer can lose the exemption by accident.
First, the dealer sorts the invoice into bullion lines (bars, ingots, qualifying coins) and non-bullion lines (jewelry, numismatic premium pieces, accessories, shipping). Only the bullion lines are candidates for exemption.
Second, the dealer compares the bullion subtotal to the $1,000 threshold. If the bullion subtotal exceeds $1,000, each bullion line is tested against the applicable TSB-M markup ratio. Lines inside the ratio band are coded exempt. Lines above the ratio band are coded taxable.
Third, the dealer applies the combined rate at the delivery address to all taxable lines. For in-store pickup, that is the store address. For a shipped order, it is the ship-to address.
Splitting one purchase across two invoices to keep both under $1,000 does not preserve the exemption. The Department of Taxation and Finance looks at structured transactions on audit and can collapse artificial splits back into a single sale. The exemption is designed for genuine investment-scale bulk purchases, and dealers who split invoices to help a customer avoid tax carry audit exposure.
Layaway and partial-payment arrangements are also a point of confusion. The tax event is the completed sale at the invoiced price. A $1,500 layaway paid in three monthly installments is still one $1,500 sale for tax purposes, and the exemption is preserved on the qualifying lines. A subscription-style monthly purchase of $500 in silver each month is twelve separate sub-threshold transactions and each is taxable in full.
New York in context: how the state compares
New York is one of a small group of states that attach a dollar threshold to the bullion exemption. California, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and Maryland all use some variation of the threshold-plus-markup approach. Most other states either exempt bullion in full or tax it in full with no threshold.
| Jurisdiction | Bullion sales tax treatment | Notes for New York buyers |
|---|---|---|
| New York State | Exempt above $1,000 per transaction with markup bands; taxable at or below $1,000 | Home-state rule; Tax Law section 1115(a)(27) and TSB-M-89(20)S |
| New Jersey | Full exemption on investment metal bullion and investment coins (as of January 1, 2026) | In-person pickup in New Jersey avoids New Jersey retail tax; New York use tax may still apply on return to a New York address |
| Connecticut | Exempt above $1,000 per transaction | Similar threshold structure to New York |
| Massachusetts | Exempt above $1,000 per transaction | Similar threshold structure to New York |
| Pennsylvania | Full exemption on investment metal bullion and investment coins | In-person pickup in Pennsylvania avoids retail tax |
Cross-border purchase strategies carry compliance risk. New York compensating use tax applies to purchases made outside the state that are brought into New York for use. Enforcement is limited on small-dollar personal purchases but the legal duty exists. Larger dollar amounts, especially where an out-of-state dealer issues an invoice or shipping record that ties the purchase to a New York buyer, are a different risk profile.
For a full survey of every state’s treatment, see the Goldiew state-by-state bullion sales tax map. For the seller side of the transaction, see Selling gold in New York, rules and reporting.
For New York dealers and coin shops reading this
New York runs one of the more technical bullion tax regimes in the country. The $1,000 threshold plus the four TSB-M markup bands plus the jewelry carve-out plus the county-by-county rate variation means dealers spend time at every register classifying lines for customers. If you run a coin shop, gold dealer, pawn shop, or jewelry buying operation in New York, being listed on Goldiew puts your address, hours, verified reviews, and category tags in front of buyers who are actively researching where to make a taxable or exempt purchase near them.
Free Goldiew business profile for New York dealers
Every New York-based gold dealer, coin dealer, jewelry buyer, and pawn shop can claim a free verified profile on Goldiew. The listing includes verified address and hours, category taxonomy so buyers researching the $1,000 exemption or the TSB-M markup bands can find you, community reviews, and integration into our state and city taxonomy maps. Claiming is free and takes a few minutes. Start at Claim your business, register at Business sign-up, or read what a Goldiew listing includes on the For business page.
Frequently asked questions
What is the current New York bullion sales tax exemption threshold?
The threshold is more than $1,000 in a single transaction, set by New York Tax Law section 1115(a)(27). The figure has not been adjusted since the exemption was enacted. A $1,001 qualifying order can be exempt; a $1,000 order is fully taxable. The exemption applies to bars, ingots, and coins of gold, silver, platinum, palladium, rhodium, ruthenium, or iridium when the sale price depends only on the metal content as defined in TSB-M-89(20)S.
What are the TSB-M-89(20)S markup ratios?
TSB-M-89(20)S sets four safe-harbor markup ratios used to determine whether a coin or bar’s price “depends only on the metal content.” Bars and ingots qualify at 115 percent of metal value or less. Gold coins larger than one-quarter ounce qualify at 115 percent. Gold coins one-quarter ounce or less qualify at 120 percent. Silver coins qualify at 140 percent. Prices above the applicable band are treated as numismatic premium and remain taxable even on orders over $1,000.
What is the sales tax rate in New York City?
The combined sales tax rate in New York City is 8.875 percent. It is made up of 4.00 percent New York State, 4.50 percent New York City local, and 0.375 percent Metropolitan Commuter Transportation District surcharge. The MCTD surcharge also applies in Nassau, Suffolk, Westchester, Rockland, Orange, Putnam, and Dutchess counties. Combined rates elsewhere in New York range from 7.00 percent to 8.875 percent depending on the county.
Is jewelry taxed in New York if the purchase is over $1,000?
Yes. Jewelry is fully taxable in New York regardless of price. The section 1115(a)(27) exemption applies only to metal in its original form as bars, ingots, or coins. Fabricated rings, chains, bracelets, and watches are taxable at the combined rate for the delivery address. A $10,000 gold chain pays sales tax; a $10,000 gold bar does not.
Are numismatic coins exempt in New York?
Only when the price falls inside the applicable TSB-M markup ratio. A graded Morgan silver dollar sold at 180 percent of melt is above the 140 percent silver-coin band and is taxable. A gold coin sold at 112 percent of melt is inside the 115 percent band and is exempt (on an order over $1,000). The test is the markup, not the age or rarity of the coin.
What happens if my New York bullion order is exactly $1,000?
The entire order is taxed at the combined state and local rate for the delivery address. The statute exempts bullion sold “for more than one thousand dollars,” so $1,000 flat does not qualify. The exemption is a strict single-transaction threshold, not a phase-in. Adding one coin or round that pushes the invoice above $1,000 flips the whole bullion portion to exempt.
Can I split a $2,000 purchase across two invoices to make each smaller?
Splitting to avoid the threshold does not preserve the exemption; it destroys it. Two $1,000 invoices structured to avoid tax on a single $2,000 sale can be collapsed on audit and both become taxable. Dealers who split invoices at customer request carry audit exposure. The practical answer is to keep the sale on a single invoice over $1,000 with each bullion line inside the TSB-M band.
Do online precious metals dealers collect New York sales tax?
Most major national dealers now collect New York sales tax at checkout on orders shipped to New York addresses that fall below the exemption threshold or outside the TSB-M markup bands. This follows the state’s economic nexus rules adopted after South Dakota v. Wayfair. Cross-check the invoice: the tax line should be zero on qualifying bullion orders over $1,000 that fall inside the markup bands, and should show the combined rate for your ship-to address on everything else.
Do I owe New York use tax if I buy bullion in Pennsylvania?
Legally yes, if you bring the bullion back to New York for use here and the item was taxable under New York law. New York compensating use tax mirrors sales tax in scope and rate for the delivery address. Enforcement against individuals on personal bullion purchases is limited, but the obligation exists and shows up on the state income tax return as a self-reported line. Large purchases with a paper trail (dealer invoice, wire transfer, shipping records tied to a New York address) carry more risk than small in-person cash purchases.
Does the New York exemption apply if I ship coins to an out-of-state depository?
Delivery to an out-of-state IRS-approved depository generally moves the transaction outside New York sales tax. For gold IRA purchases where the dealer ships directly from an out-of-state warehouse to a Delaware or Texas depository, no New York retail sale is happening and the transaction is generally not subject to New York tax. Confirm the tax treatment with the dealer before the transaction; the answer depends on the dealer’s nexus, shipping route, and invoice mechanics.
Are gold ETFs like GLD taxed as bullion purchases in New York?
No. Shares of gold-backed exchange-traded funds are securities purchased through a broker, not tangible personal property. Sales tax does not apply. The tax question for ETFs is entirely federal income tax on capital gains, where the IRS applies the 28 percent collectibles rate to gains on physically backed precious metals ETFs.
Sources
- New York Tax Law section 1115(a)(27): statutory basis for the exemption on bullion “sold for investment” with the more-than-$1,000 threshold and the metal-content pricing requirement
- New York TSB-M-89(20)S: administrative guidance translating the statute into the 115 percent (bars, large gold coins), 120 percent (small gold coins), and 140 percent (silver coins) markup ratios
- New York State Sales Tax Rates: 4.00 percent statewide base rate, 0.375 percent MCTD surcharge, and county-by-county combined rates
- New York City Department of Finance: NYS Sales Tax: breakdown of the 8.875 percent New York City combined rate
- New York State Department of Taxation and Finance: state tax agency that administers sales, use, and local option taxes
- South Dakota v. Wayfair, Inc. (U.S. Supreme Court, 2018): constitutional basis for state economic nexus rules that require out-of-state dealers to collect New York sales tax
- IRS Publication 590-A: federal rules for self-directed precious metals IRAs, relevant to out-of-state depository shipments that fall outside New York sales tax
- FINRA Investor Alert: Precious Metals Fraud: consumer protection context for precious metals purchases
- Goldiew: State Sales Tax on Bullion Map: full 50-state survey of bullion tax treatment
- Goldiew: Sales Tax on Bullion in California: California threshold rule for comparison
- Goldiew: Sales Tax on Bullion in New Jersey: neighboring state treatment
- Goldiew: Gold IRA New York Residents Guide: New York-specific guide to the retirement account side of precious metals ownership
- Goldiew: Gold Value Calculator: independent spot-based check on bar and coin melt value
- Goldiew New York Gold Dealer Directory: verified in-state dealers by city
- Goldiew New York Coin Dealer Directory: verified in-state coin dealers by city
- Goldiew for Business: how New York dealers can claim a free verified listing