Island Rarities

Name: Island Rarities
Address: 130 Knickerbocker Ave, Bohemia, NY, 11716
Telephone: +1 844-263-2646
Rating: 4.67

4.67 • Excellent ReputationBased on 3 reviews

Visit website

Own this business? Click here to claim it.

Island Rarities is a coin dealer in Bohemia, New York, rated 4.67 out of 5 from 3 customer reviews published on Goldiew.

Call Directions

COIN COLLECTORSSelling collectible coins?Key dates and rarities are worth more than melt value. Learn what to check before you sell.Check collectible value →FREE SERVICEGet competing offers for your coinsDescribe your items once and rated buyers quote their best price. Free, private, and your contact stays hidden until you accept an offer.Get my offers →

★ 4.67

All reviews

Average rating based on 3 reviews

4 months ago

A peaceful coin shop with friendly staff and great selection

Quiet shop, good lighting, no weird vibes. The selection of coins was impressive and well-organized which made browsing enjoyable. Staff seemed knowledgeable but not overly pushy which I really appreciated because I like to take my time without feeling rushed. They answered my questions clearly and gave honest advice on some rare finds that caught my eye. Prices felt fair based on the market values too so it put me at ease about making a purchase or trade. This store suited my mood perfectly today, relaxed but still genuinely interested in learning more about coins and collecting them properly now. Will definitely come back soon for another visit!

Date: April 27, 2026 · Ref. ID: #42680

4 months ago

This place totally rocked!

Wow, this place totally rocked! couldnt believe how many cool coins they had. the legend warp on some pieces is awsome, def coming back for more!!

Date: April 13, 2026 · Ref. ID: #41939

12 months ago

Could use more value for the price but friendly enough

Treading into this coin dealer’s shop left me feeling a bit unsure. The selection was decent but not quite as impressive as I hoped for the price points . Staff seemed friendly enough, though they didn’t offer much guidance which made it hard to gauge if I was getting a good deal . There were some interesting pieces, but everything felt somewhat overpriced or maybe just not what I expected lingering in my mind afterward . It wasn’t exactly disappointing, yet nothing stood out enough to recommend wholeheartedly . Overall okay experience but lacking that extra touch of worthiness, might try elsewhere next time unless specific rare coins catch my eye again.

Date: August 28, 2025 · Ref. ID: #29636

Looking for similar businesses near Island Rarities?
Click to explore related listings.

Before you sell your coins

Business details

Island Rarities is a Coin dealer located at 130 Knickerbocker Ave, Bohemia, NY 11716. Here is a list of all the activities that Island Rarities specializes in: Coin dealer.

Contact info

http://islandrarities.com/
+1 844-263-2646
[email protected]
130 Knickerbocker Ave, Bohemia, NY 11716
11716

Open Hours

Closed · Opens tomorrow 10:30 AM

Monday: 10:30 AM-5:30 PM
Tuesday: 10:30 AM-5:30 PM
Wednesday: 10:30 AM-5:30 PM
Thursday: 10:30 AM-5:30 PM
Friday: 10:30 AM-5:30 PM
Saturday: 10 AM-2 PM
Sunday: Closed

Opening hours and open/closed status for Island Rarities are shown based on their local time zone.

Time Zone

America/New_York

Services offered by Island Rarities

Discover the services provided by Island Rarities, grouped by category to help you understand what they specialize in.

Island Rarities has not claimed this page yet. Services listed have not been verified directly by the business.

Bullion products

Gold bullion rounds

Silver bullion bars / rounds

Certified rare coins

Raw collectible coins

Junk‑silver bags

Coin accessories

Buying services

Buy gold bullion

Buy rare coins

Price‑match guarantee

Repairs & appraisals

Professional cleaning

Coin grading submission

Estate appraisal

Pawn & financing services

Pawn loans on bullion/coins

Business categories & location

See what type of business Island Rarities is and where they operate. Click any state or city to explore more businesses of the same type in that location.

Gold dealer

Coin dealer

Jewelry buyer

About Island Rarities

Island Rarities is a business located in Bohemia, New York that provides coin dealing services. The business specializes in selling rare coins and collectibles to customers. The company is a reputable coin dealer that seeks to provide high-quality services to its clients. The location is easily accessible to potential clients seeking to buy or sell coins and collectibles. It should be noted that this description is based on factual data only and aims to be unbiased; it does not indicate the reliability or any other factors related to the business.

Verified social profiles

This business has not added any verified social profiles yet.

How Island Rarities Measures Up on Our Safety Index
Rating & Label	Meaning
5.00 - 4.50 ✅ Excellent Reputation	Consistently rated highly by users. Strong trustworthiness.
4.49 - 3.80 🟢 Good Standing	Generally well-reviewed with some concerns.
3.79 - 2.80 ⚠️ Mixed Feedback	Reviews vary; some report good experiences, others have concerns.
2.79 - 1.80 🟠 Needs Improvement	Multiple negative reviews highlight recurring issues.
1.79 - 1.00 🔴 Poor Reputation	Generally low-rated with significant concerns.
⏳ Awaiting Reviews	This company has not been reviewed yet.

Note: The Safety Index for Island Rarities is based on an average user rating of 4.67 from 3 user reviews. This rating determines the company’s reputation level: Excellent Reputation.