Overall okay but pricing could be clearer
Finding a good coin dealer can be tricky sometimes. I’ve dealt with a few over the years, and while Caldwell Coins has its moments, it didn’t quite blow me away. The staff was friendly enough when I went in to browse their collection, which is always appreciated. On the other hand, pricing felt somewhat inconsistent compared to online options they recommended checking, so that part left me wanting more transparency. They definitely have some interesting pieces for collectors or investors looking nearby but might not stand out as my top go-to spot overall. If you’re local and just starting your collection or want quick access without too much fuss morning visits work fine itself; otherwise there could be better bargains elsewhere on certain items worth exploring first around town entirely genuine in intentions though!